Quantcast
Channel: Opinionator » Gary Gutting
Browsing all 75 articles
Browse latest View live

Facts, Arguments and Politics

In political debates, getting the facts right doesn't guarantee a valid argument.

View Article



Haidt's Problem With Plato

In "The Righteous Mind," Jonathan Haidt argues that psychologists have overturned philosophers' view of reason. But there are ways for the two groups to work together.

View Article

How Not to Choose a President

It is easy to think of any competitive situation as a sporting event. But presidential debates are perhaps the best example of the sports analogy gone wrong.

View Article

Who Should You Vote For?

A brief guide for the undecided.

View Article

Learning History at the Movies

Films like "Lincoln" can contribute to our understanding of past events, but on their own, they are no substitute for the work of historians.

View Article


Praising Andy Warhol

Perhaps anything, no matter how it looks, can be a work of art. But that does not mean that everything is.

View Article

The N.R.A.'s Blockade on Science

There is no scientific consensus on the best approach to limiting gun violence, and the N.R.A. is blocking work that might lead to one.

View Article

The Joy of Zadie Smith and Thomas Aquinas

Bringing together the writing of two very different thinkers to illuminate a fundamental question.

View Article


The Way of the Agnostic

What do believers have to believe?

View Article


Depression and the Limits of Psychiatry

The recent revisions to the DSM's definition of depression are based on a questionable conception of what is "normal." Why is that dangerous?

View Article

A Great Debate

Is there a way to make genuine debates, in which politicians must do more than just repeat talking points, part of our political culture?

View Article

Mary and the Zombies: Can Science Explain Consciousness?

Is a purely physical, scientific account of subjective experience possible?

View Article

Mary and the Zombies: Consciousness Revisited

The author responds to readers' theories on whether consciousness can be explained by science.

View Article


On Being Catholic

Can reflective and honest intellectuals actually believe in the church's teachings?

View Article

Happiness, Beyond the Data

Our first-person experience and reflection can catch crucial truths about happiness that escape the quantitative net.

View Article


What Do Scientific Studies Show?

Stories claiming to report useful scientific breakthroughs appear in the news media every day. But what use are they if they are so frequently reversed?

View Article

Why Do I Teach?

We should judge teaching not by the amount of knowledge it passes on, but by the enduring excitement it generates.

View Article


You Say You Want a Revolution

Is the Obama administration really the sort of oppressive government that needs to be overthrown?

View Article

Mozart vs. the Beatles

Is one kind of art better than another?

View Article

Did Zeus Exist?

We are in no position to say that he did. But are we really in a position to say that he didn't?

View Article
Browsing all 75 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images